A North Carolina couple noticed their new home’s kitchen floor dipping within weeks of moving in in 2016, then sued the builder years later; an appeals court has rejected their defective-construction claims

1795223152 photo



Representational AI image/ChatGPT

A North Carolina couple noticed that their new home’s kitchen floor had a major dip within weeks of moving in in 2016. They contacted the builder, and a representative came to the house to stabilise the affected area. But years later, after consulting a contractor, they became concerned that the house had been built on an improperly sloped foundation.The couple eventually sued the builder in January 2025, seeking damages over alleged construction defects. However, the North Carolina Court of Appeals has rejected their claims, ruling that they waited too long to take legal action and did not provide enough evidence to support some of their other allegations, according to Law Justia.In its November 18, 2026, judgment in Holton v. Value Build Homes, the court upheld an earlier decision granting summary judgment to the builders. The case was brought by Nate Holton and Christine Holton against Value Build Homes and related companies.

Floor problem appeared shortly after moving in

According to the court’s judgment, the couple signed a contract with Value Build Homes on November 15, 2015, for the construction of a house in Moore County, North Carolina. The home received its certificate of occupancy on May 17, 2016, allowing the couple to move in.Within 30 to 60 days, they noticed what the court described as a “substantial dip in the kitchen floor”. They contacted the builders, and a representative visited the property and stabilised the affected area.The couple also signed an application for a builder’s limited warranty with Professional Warranty Service Corporation on October 14, 2016. The warranty provided different levels of coverage for 10 years from May 17, 2016, and required disputes to be settled through binding arbitration.The issue came up again in October 2023, when the couple consulted a crawlspace contractor. They became concerned that the house had been built on an improperly sloped foundation.On November 8, 2023, Nate Holton contacted the builders and said, “The house was never level since day 1.” The builders investigated the complaint in 2024, excavating near the foundation and taking measurements. The couple filed their lawsuit on January 17, 2025. They accused the companies of breach of contract, breach of express and implied warranties, defective construction, negligence and unfair and deceptive trade practices.

Why the court rejected the claims

Photo: Canva

Photo: Canva

The couple argued that the six-year legal deadline should be counted from 2023, when they became concerned about the foundation, rather than from 2016, when the house was completed. But the appeals court disagreed. It said the home was substantially complete no later than May 17, 2016, the date its certificate of occupancy was issued. North Carolina law generally does not allow claims over defective construction to be filed more than six years after substantial completion or the relevant last act or omission by the defendant.The court also rejected the argument that the builders’ later involvement extended this period. It found that the couple had not provided evidence that the builders carried out repairs after 2016 under the original construction contract. Their work in 2024 involved investigating the complaint and taking measurements, not repairing the house.The couple also relied on the 10-year structural warranty. However, the judges said they had not identified a specific warranty provision that the builders had breached or shown evidence of a particular obligation imposed on them. The warranty was administered through Professional Warranty Service Corporation, against which the couple had voluntarily dismissed their claims with prejudice in April 2026.The court therefore concluded that the construction-related claims were filed outside the six-year period. It also considered the separate time limits for filing lawsuits. Contract and negligence claims had a three-year limitation period, while the unfair and deceptive trade practices claim had a four-year period.The judges said the couple knew about the floor problem in 2016 because they had noticed the dip and contacted the builders. They did not need to know the exact cause or full extent of the defect for the legal time limit to begin. The couple waited more than eight years after discovering the problem to file their lawsuit.

Court also rejects negligence and deception claims

The couple’s negligence claim argued that the builders had failed to construct the home properly and sought compensation for the loss in the property’s value and the cost of repairs. The court rejected this claim under North Carolina’s economic loss rule. It said the couple had not identified a duty owed by the builders that was separate from their contractual obligations. Since the damages involved financial losses arising from the alleged failure to meet the construction contract, they could not be recovered through a negligence claim.The couple also accused the builders of concealing the defect and making inaccurate statements about the foundation. The court said that even if these allegations were true, they had not shown a separate financial loss caused by the alleged deception. The damages they sought were the same as those claimed for the construction problems.The ruling does not establish that the house had no construction defects. It means the couple’s claims could not proceed because of the legal time limits and the lack of evidence needed to support their remaining allegations.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *