A New York woman says she lived in an apartment for 20 years, but the landlord required her company to sign a commercial lease for residential space; an appeals court has allowed her rent-stabilisation fight to continue

1795259801 photo



Representative Image (AI-generated)

A New York landlord’s attempt to recover possession of an apartment has suffered a setback after an appeals court allowed a long-running dispute over rent-stabilisation protections to proceed. The case centres on E. Terese Carpenter, who says she has lived in a Manhattan apartment for more than 20 years, even though the landlord required a company she owned to sign a commercial lease describing the space as being used exclusively for business. In a November 19, 2026 decision, available on Justia, the New York Supreme Court’s Appellate Division, First Department, upheld a lower court’s refusal to grant the landlord summary judgment, finding that there were unresolved questions about the apartment’s actual residential use and the landlord’s knowledge of it. The ruling in 38 E. 64th St., LLC v. Nile, Inc. allows Carpenter’s rent-stabilisation claims to continue.

Landlord sought to recover the Manhattan apartment

The dispute involves an apartment in a building at 38 East 64th Street in Manhattan. The landlord, 38 East 64th Street, LLC, rented the unit to Nile, Inc., a company owned by Carpenter, beginning in or around 2006. Although the premises were an apartment, the landlord required Nile to enter into a commercial lease stating that the space would be used exclusively for business purposes. The building’s certificate of occupancy, however, permitted only residential use.Carpenter maintained that she had always intended to use the apartment as her home and had actually lived there for more than two decades. The defendants argued that the landlord knew about and accepted this residential occupation despite the wording of the commercial lease. The landlord subsequently brought an action seeking possession of the apartment and payment for its use and occupancy. It also sought attorneys’ fees under the lease agreement.Nile and Carpenter contested the action, arguing that the apartment remained subject to New York’s Rent Stabilisation Law and that the commercial lease arrangement had been used to remove the unit improperly from rent regulation.

Tenant challenges the commercial lease arrangement

The dispute raised an important question about whether the description of a property in a lease is enough to determine its legal status when the actual use of the premises is different. The defendants argued that Carpenter’s long-term residential occupation, together with the landlord’s knowledge and acceptance of that arrangement, meant that the apartment could still qualify for rent-stabilisation protections.They also brought counterclaims alleging that the landlord had illegally and fraudulently deregulated the unit. If established, their claims could entitle Carpenter to a court declaration recognising her as the lawful rent-stabilised tenant. The landlord, meanwhile, sought summary judgment in its favour and asked the court to dismiss the defendants’ counterclaims and affirmative defences. In May 2025, New York County Supreme Court Justice Lyle E Frank denied the landlord’s application. The landlord appealed that decision to the First Department.

Appeals court finds questions about residential use

The Appellate Division examined whether the evidence raised factual questions that needed to be resolved before the landlord could obtain judgment without a trial. The judges noted that the defendants had submitted sufficient evidence to raise a question about whether the apartment was being used for residential purposes with the landlord’s knowledge and acquiescence.The court referred to an earlier First Department ruling, Hadzovic v. Buckley School in the City of New York, which established that disputes involving mixed residential and commercial use must initially be resolved by a factfinder. It also noted that the landlord did not dispute the defendants’ assertion that it had required them to sign a commercial lease exclusively for business use, despite the building’s certificate of occupancy allowing only residential occupation.Furthermore, the landlord had failed to provide evidence contradicting Carpenter’s claim that she had always intended to live in the apartment and had actually done so for more than 20 years. The court also found that the defendants had sufficiently stated their counterclaims concerning the apartment’s rent-stabilised status and alleged illegal deregulation.

Landlord’s appeal unanimously rejected

On November 19, 2026, the First Department unanimously affirmed the lower court’s order, without costs. This means the landlord did not obtain the summary judgment or dismissal of the defendants’ claims it had sought. However, the ruling does not finally establish that Carpenter is a rent-stabilised tenant or that the landlord illegally deregulated the apartment. Those issues remain to be determined through further proceedings.The decision means that the commercial lease cannot, by itself, end the dispute over the apartment’s residential use and potential rent-stabilised status. Carpenter and Nile can continue pursuing their claims, while the landlord’s action to recover possession and use and occupancy remains unresolved.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *